John perry in his dialogue on personal identity and immortality displayed four theories of personal identity body theory, soul theory, memory theory and brain theory, each of which has its advantages and its problems. Formulate the criterion of personal identity proposed by cohen during the second night of the perry dialogue: person a (at an earlier time) is numerically the same as person b (at the. Lecture on chapter three of perry's a dialogue on personal identity and immortality chapter three.
Name _____ date_____ quiz -perry – a dialogue on personal identity and immortality 1 how does gretchen criticize sam's proposal (in the first night) that the same person is present on two different occasions just in case (or, exactly when) the same soul is present on those two occasions. Additional info for a dialogue on personal identity and immortality sample text the categories of on-line service include bibliographic, which merely indexes the existence of an article or book--you must then find a physical copy to read and source, which contains the article or extract thereof. In this paper, i offer an explication of john perry’s arguments on pages 27-30 of his dialogue on personal identity and immortality in this excerpt from the dialogue, the two primary characters, miller and weirob, engage in discussion dealing with the connection between memory, identity, and survival.
Perry (1978) a dialogue n personal identity 3 miller: there could be an identical box of kleenex at your home, one just like it in every respect and, in this sense, there is no difficulty in there being someone identical to you in the hereafter, though. The contemporary philosopher john perry, in the three-night dialogue, creates a discussion wrapped around the connection of the soul with personal identity he gives an example of julia and mary. - personal identity nell bernstein is the author of goin' gangsta, choosin' cholita: claiming identity, an essay describing how the youth in certain parts of the country are choosing their preferred identity rather than accepting their own.
The buddhist view of personal identity is also a no-self theory rather than a reductionist theory, because the buddha rejects attempts to reconstructions in terms of consciousness, john perry, a dialogue on personal identity and immortality indianapolis, hackett, 1978. A dialogue on personal identity and immortality perry 1 stephen e schmid first night 3 stephen e schmid uw-rock county intro to philosophy •weirob grants this theory but denies that it can explain survival after death. Theories of personal identity same soul theory: a person at one time is the very same person as a person at a later time if and only if they have the very same immaterial soul same soul same person.
Lectures: perry i the problem of personal identity iv sam's first theory: personal identity is based on the sameness of immaterial soul refers to the work of descartes: the soul is not the same as the body viii objections to gretchen's theory at the end of the first dialogue, gretchen claims that her own belief is that a person. Personal identity and immortality i some background concerning human understanding, book ii, chapter 27, and is developed in perry’s dialogue) (3) animalism: you are the same person over time if and only if there is a continuity of in the second night, miller tries a new tack, arguing for a “stage theory” of personal identity. P42-3: miller and cohen return to endorsing the idea that memory is sufficient for identity and the brain transplants preserve memory weirob then suggests that if such an account should be able to explain why personal identity is important in terms of why memory is important.
In the beginning of the ‘second night’ of perry’s dialogue, we get some objections to the idea that the self just is the body this is a view to which we will return most of this part of the dialogue is devoted to the idea that personal identity is a matter of some kind of psychological. Perry's dialogue on personal identity and immortality first night - duration: 10:17 matt deaton 3,292 views 10:17 a dialogue to kill the fear of public speaking personal identity,. In perry’s dialogue on personal identity and immortality there is a conversation between three characters that lasted over a period of three nights the way the dialogue of the conversation was set up was that each night the topic of the argument will get more intense , tricky and complicated.
Perry – a dialogue on personal identity and immortality the first day: weirob’s challenge to miller (p 397): show me how it could even be so much as possible that i survive the death and destruction of my material body. A second advantage they claim for psychological continuity theories is that these theories explain why personal identity is important they explain why we care about it for on psychological continuity theories, personal identity consists in the preservation of one's personality and memories--and these are the sorts of properties that we value. 3 theories of personal identity • same soul theory: a person at one time is the very same person as a person at a later time if and only if they have the very same immaterial soul • problems • i can tell if you are the same person, but i can’t tell if you have the same soul.